Cosmetic Dentistry 
General Dentistry 
Restorative Dentistry 
Dental Implants 
Orthodontics 
Sleep Dentistry 
Emergency Dentist 
Children’s Dentist Realising that a root canal treatment hasn’t gone as planned can understandably cause concern. You might have hoped that the pain and infection were behind you, only to find that symptoms have returned or worsened. While this experience can be frustrating, it’s important to know that you’re not alone — root canal treatments can fail, and it happens more often than most people think.
A failed root canal treatment doesn’t mean the end of the road for your tooth. In fact, there are several clinically recognised options for a failed root canal, each tailored to suit different circumstances. With the right assessment and care, many patients successfully manage this situation and regain comfort and function.
This article is intended for educational purposes only. It does not replace personalised advice from a dental professional. Always consult your dentist to explore treatment options based on your individual needs and clinical findings.
Contents Navigation
Summary of The Content
- Root canal failure is not uncommon and can occur weeks or years after the initial procedure.
- Common symptoms include persistent pain, swelling, a boil on the gums, or tooth discolouration.
- Causes of failure may include missed canals, bacterial contamination, or delays in dental crown placement.
- Non-surgical retreatment may be suitable if enough healthy tooth structure remains.
- A systematic review reports a 77% success rate for root canal retreatment, depending on various factors.
- Apicoectomy may be recommended when retreatment isn’t possible or has not cleared the infection.
- Tooth extraction may be necessary if the tooth structure is too compromised or infection persists.
- Tooth replacement options include implants, bridges, and partial dentures, and each has its pros and limitations.
- Choosing the right treatment depends on your clinical situation, oral health, and personal preferences.
- Early consultation with your dentist is essential for successful outcomes.
Understanding Root Canal Therapy Failure
Root canal therapy is a common treatment option for managing infection and preserving the natural tooth. While generally successful, root canal treatments fail in a small percentage of cases. A 2024 study published in BMC Oral Health found that around 7% to 18% of root canals are unsuccessful, with early failure often linked to canals that were not fully located or cleaned during the initial root canal treatment.
A root canal treatment is considered a failure when healing doesn’t occur, or the infected tooth becomes symptomatic again. This might happen weeks or even years after the initial procedure and may not always be obvious without a dental X-ray. Dentists diagnose failure by reviewing symptoms, imaging, and performing a clinical examination.
What Causes a Root Canal Treatment to Fail?
Several factors can lead to root canal treatment failure, including:
- Curved or narrow canals that may not be thoroughly cleaned during the initial treatment, allowing infection to persist
- The use of filling materials or sealants that fail to create a complete seal, allowing gaps where bacteria can persist and multiply
- Bacterial contamination, which can occur if saliva contaminates the canal either during or after the procedure
- Failure to place a dental crown in a timely or effective manner, leaving the tooth vulnerable to breakage and reinfection
- Tooth fracture, which may allow the bacteria to re-enter the inner structures of the tooth
Other risk factors may include traumatic dental injuries, contamination from salivary bacteria, or delays in completing the crown after your root canal treatment. These situations may lead to reinfection, which can manifest as persistent tooth pain or abscess formation. Visible symptoms may include gum tenderness or the presence of a boil, which can interfere with routine activities such as eating and negatively affect overall daily comfort.
While the overall failure rate of root canal treatment is relatively low, it is important to recognise that dental procedures may not always provide long-term results. Fortunately, a range of treatments is available for a failed root canal treatment. Early diagnosis and prompt treatment can help preserve the natural tooth and prevent more serious complications.
Signs and Symptoms of a Failed Root Canal Procedure
Root canal treatment is performed to address infection within the pulp or nerve tissue of a tooth. While mild discomfort is commonly experienced in the days following the procedure, this typically resolves on its own. However, if pain persists or additional symptoms develop, it may indicate treatment failure and warrant further evaluation.
Common signs of root canal treatment failure include:
- Persistent or worsening tooth pain:
Pain continues beyond the usual recovery period and may interfere with daily activities. - Swelling of the gums:
The gums around the involved tooth may appear puffy, tender, or warm. - Pimple-like bump or boil on the gums:
A small bump may form on the surrounding gum area and may release fluid. This is called a sinus tract. - Tenderness when biting or applying pressure:
The tooth may feel sore when chewing or touched. - Visible concerns on a dental X-ray:
A dental X-ray may reveal indications of a fracture, previously undetected anatomical variations, or issues related to the previous root canal filling.
Common causes of these symptoms include:
- Blockage or salivary contamination:
Bacteria or fluids may enter the root canal system during or after the procedure and cause reinfection. - Gaps in filling material:
The filling material may leave open spaces that allow bacteria to remain in the tooth. - Missed canals:
Curved or narrow canals may be overlooked, potentially leaving portions of the root canal system that are inadequately cleaned.
Symptoms that necessitate prompt attention include:
- The pain in the affected tooth becomes more intense and persists over time.
- The swelling spreads to the jaw or across the face and becomes more noticeable.
- There is a persistent bad taste or unpleasant taste in the mouth.
- Pus or fluid leaks from the gum tissue near the site of the affected tooth.
These symptoms may lead to the need for:
- A retreatment to address the infection and replace the filling material inside the canals.
- Apical surgery to access the root tip if entry is not possible.
- Extraction of the tooth, followed by placement of a dental implant, bridge, or denture, if keeping the tooth is not an option.
Although the success rate, which implies a low failure rate, attests to the general effectiveness of endodontic procedures, symptoms like these should not be ignored.
If your root canal treatment causes pain or discomfort that feels unusual, speak with your dentist. They can assess your tooth and, if necessary, use a dental X-ray to confirm root canal treatment failure.
Option 1: Root Canal Retreatment
In some cases, one of the most suitable options for a failed root canal treatment is to repeat the procedure on the tooth. This is known as non-surgical retreatment. It involves re-entering the root canal system to clean out the infection and place a new filling material.
During retreatment:
- The existing filling material is removed from the root canals.
- The dentist conducts a thorough examination of the root canal anatomy, carefully identifying any missed or unusually narrow canals that may have contributed to the failure of the initial root canal treatment.
- The canals are thoroughly irrigated to disinfect or remove any remaining bacteria and reduce the risk of reinfection.
- The tooth is sealed with a tooth-filling material to promote healing.
This option is considered when:
- There is enough healthy tooth structure remaining.
- The crown placed following the initial root canal treatment can be safely removed without compromising the integrity of the underlying tooth structure.
- There are no significant structural issues, such as vertical root fractures or cracks, that would compromise the potential for a successful outcome.
While a small percentage of root canal treatments may not succeed, retreatment provides an important opportunity to preserve the natural tooth.
A systematic review published in the International Endodontic Journal found that the pooled success rate of non-surgical retreatment is approximately 77%. The outcome can vary based on several factors, including the shape of the canals, the presence of any pre-existing periapical conditions, and whether the canals were thoroughly cleaned and sealed during the previous procedure.
This treatment option for failed root canal treatment may not be suitable if the tooth has extensive decay, fractures, or has lost too much structure to support a restoration. It is also contraindicated if the patient has poor oral hygiene, medical conditions that prevent treatment or low motivation or cooperation.
Aftercare and recovery:
Recovery is generally manageable and usually involves minor discomfort. Proper care helps the healing process.
- Mild soreness after a root canal retreatment may last for a few days.
- Over-the-counter pain relief medication and proper care can help reduce discomfort.
- A temporary filling may be placed before the final dental crown placement.
- Healing time depends on the tooth’s response and whether there are any complications.
- Most people return to routine tasks within a few days or a week after completion of treatment.
When further steps may be needed:
Not all retreatments succeed. In some cases, the infection persists or recurs.
- The infected tooth exhibits continuous pain or signs of infection, including a boil or swelling.
- These symptoms indicate that the bacterial infection level remains elevated, and the body is unable to manage it effectively despite retreatment.
In the event of root canal treatment failure, retreatment is considered the first option before contemplating endodontic surgery or extraction.
Option 2: Apicoectomy (Root-End Surgery)
When non-surgical retreatment is not possible or has not cleared the issue, another option for failed root canal cases is an apicoectomy. This minor surgical procedure involves accessing the root tip through the gum tissue, removing the affected end of the root, and sealing the canal.
Apicoectomy is recommended when:
- There is a persistent infection at the root tip that remains after endodontic treatment.
- A blockage or salivary contamination obstructs a dentist’s attempt to clean the canal.
- There are structural anomalies, such as curved canals, making traditional retreatment difficult.
A dentist performs the procedure to manage root pathology and address canals that may have been missed during the initial procedure.
Steps involved in apicoectomy:
- The dentist numbs the area and makes a small incision in the gum tissue near the site of the root.
- A small portion of the root tip is removed along with infected tissue.
- The root canal end is cleaned and sealed to prevent reinfection.
Modern microsurgical techniques and imaging have improved the treatment method’s overall efficacy. An apicoectomy can have a success rate between 70% and 90%, depending on factors such as the root canal structure and the presence of infection in the tooth.
Aftercare and recovery:
- Mild swelling and discomfort are common and may last for a few days.
- Pain relief and following care instructions promote healing.
- Most people return to their usual everyday life and perform routine tasks within a few days.
This procedure may be an option when:
- Previous non-surgical retreatment has failed to manage symptoms or radiographic signs of infection.
- Presence of root-end anomalies such as fractures, resorption, or perforations near the root tip
- The root canal system is obstructed (e.g., by a post, broken instrument, or calcification), preventing adequate cleaning and sealing.
- Retreatment is not practical due to complex root anatomy or the presence of restorative or prosthetic work that cannot be disturbed.
While root canal treatments are frequently successful, canals can fail owing to a range of factors. In these cases, an apicoectomy may help preserve your tooth when other approaches are no longer suitable.
Talk to your dentist if you’re concerned about root canal treatment causing symptoms or if you notice symptoms that require intervention. Apicoectomy is often considered when the goal is to preserve the natural structure rather than remove the tooth entirely.
Option 3: Tooth Extraction and Replacement Options
In some cases, keeping the natural tooth may not be possible. Extraction may be recommended when the tooth has a vertical root fracture, a significant portion of the tooth is missing, or when a persistent infection remains after other endodontic procedures. It may also be necessary when the surrounding bone or gum tissue has been compromised due to periodontal disease.
A tooth may be indicated for extraction if the tooth’s roots are too thin or too weak to undergo another root canal procedure or if a previous retreatment or apicoectomy fails to remove infection completely. These situations may lead to continued symptoms, and without proper treatment, contaminating bacteria can spread throughout nearby tissues.
After extraction, several tooth replacement options are available to help restore function, comfort, and appearance. Each approach has its benefits and limitations, depending on your goals, oral health, and preferences.
Dental Implants
Dental implants are a widely used option for replacing missing teeth. They involve placing a titanium post into the jawbone, which supports a dental crown. Implants aim to restore appearance, function, and stability while preventing bone loss in the area where the extracted tooth once was.
Pros:
- Dental implants offer a high level of stability and can remain functional for many years with good care and maintenance.
- They help maintain the shape and density of the jawbone, which supports the facial structure and improves comfort during everyday life, making routine activities like eating and speaking easier.
- Because they are independent structures, dental implants do not require support from neighbouring teeth.
Cons:
- Placement of dental implants involves a minor surgical procedure, which may not be suitable for all individuals.
- People with limited bone density or systemic conditions or who are taking certain medications may not be ideal candidates.
- The process can take time, as the bone needs to integrate with the implant before the final crown is attached.
Timeline and Maintenance:
- The full procedure may span several months, from the initial post-placement to the final restoration.
- Regular brushing, flossing, and dental visits are essential to protect the implant and the surrounding gum tissue.
Dental implants may be ideal for individuals seeking a long-term tooth replacement option with minimal impact on surrounding teeth. Your dentist will assess if this is appropriate based on your oral and general health.
Dental Bridges
Dental bridges are prosthetic restorations that remain securely in place and are used to replace one or more missing teeth. They anchor to the natural teeth on either side of the space and hold a false tooth in place. This method is often considered when the surrounding teeth are strong enough to support a replacement tooth.
Pros:
- Bridges can often be completed more quickly than implants and do not involve surgical procedures.
- They provide improved function and appearance, allowing patients to chew, speak, and smile with more confidence.
Cons:
- The supporting teeth need to be reshaped to make space for the bridge.
- Food particles and plaque can become trapped underneath, making hygiene maintenance more challenging and requiring additional care.
Timeline and Maintenance:
- The entire process usually takes a few weeks and involves multiple appointments for preparation and fitting.
- Daily cleaning under the bridge using floss or special brushes, along with regular dental visits, helps maintain good oral health.
Dental bridges are suitable restorations when the neighbouring teeth are strong enough to provide support or when implants are not preferred.
Removable Partial Dentures
Removable partial dentures are custom-made appliances designed to replace one or more missing teeth. They often consist of a metal or acrylic base with artificial teeth attached and are held in place using clasps or other attachments.
Pros:
- This is a more affordable option for replacing missing teeth, especially when multiple spaces are present.
- Dentures do not require surgery or alteration of adjacent teeth, making them a less invasive option.
Cons:
- They may feel bulky and require an adjustment period to get used to speaking and chewing.
- Dentures are generally less stable than non-removable options and may shift slightly during use.
Timeline and Maintenance:
- The treatment process can often be completed within a few weeks, depending on the adjustments needed.
- Daily removal for cleaning and overnight soaking helps maintain the denture’s cleanliness and prevents complications.
Removable partial dentures may be appropriate for patients who prefer a non-surgical, cost-effective approach or who are not candidates for bridges or implants.
Each replacement option has benefits and drawbacks, and the most suitable choice depends on individual oral health, available bone support, lifestyle, and preferences. Your dentist will discuss the available options based on their assessment and your needs to help you decide how to move forward confidently.
How to Choose the Right Option for You
Selecting the most suitable option for managing a failed root canal treatment depends on several factors. Each person’s situation is different, and what works for one may not be right for another.
Your choice may involve retreatment, apicoectomy, or removal of the tooth, followed by a tooth replacement. The decision is made through a detailed consultation and clinical assessment by your dentist.
A comprehensive dental examination will take into account the following considerations:
- Your dentist will evaluate how much healthy tooth structure remains.
- They will consider the position of the tooth in your mouth and how it affects your bite and chewing.
- The overall condition of your gums and oral health will be examined.
- Your bone quality and volume will be assessed to determine if you are suitable for restorations like implants.
- Your medical history, including current health conditions and medications you are taking, will be discussed.
- Your preferences regarding treatment time, maintenance, and invasiveness will be taken into consideration.
- The cost of each treatment option and your budget will also be a factor in the discussion.
These elements help your dentist recommend a treatment option that aligns with your dental health needs and long-term goals.
To help guide your discussion, you may consider asking:
- Is retreatment a possible option for this tooth?
- What are the risks or limitations of keeping the tooth compared to removing it?
- How long does each tooth replacement option typically last?
- What care and maintenance are involved for each option?
- How many visits are needed to complete each procedure?
- Do my medical conditions affect the choice of treatment?
Because every patient has unique clinical needs and personal preferences, your dentist will provide guidance based on both your examination findings and the goals you hope to achieve. The outcome is a treatment plan that is tailored specifically for you.
Final Thoughts
Discovering that a previous procedure hasn’t worked as expected can feel discouraging, but it’s important to know that options for a failed root canal treatment do exist. Whether the option involves retreatment, apicoectomy, or replacing the tooth entirely, there are clinical pathways designed to manage the problem and support your comfort.
Many patients experience positive outcomes once the problem is diagnosed and addressed. Prompt evaluation by a dental professional is essential for understanding the cause of symptoms and choosing the right course of action. The earlier these concerns are assessed, the more likely it is that further complications can be avoided.
If you’re experiencing symptoms or have been told your root canal treatment has failed, we encourage you to schedule a consultation at Karrinyup Dental Centre. You can call us on (08) 9341 6233 or email info@karrinyupdental.com.au to make an appointment. Our team will take the time to assess your specific needs and discuss all appropriate options with you.
You don’t have to manage this on your own. We’re here to help you move forward with clarity, comfort, and care.
